At ASCO 2018, Dr. Melissa Loh presented a study titled: "Chance of Cure in Advanced Cancer: What Do Older Patients Believe and How Are These Beliefs Related to Their Preferences?". This study looked at patients and their beliefs regarding a cure for cancer, specifically in older patients with advanced cancer. Patients who are certain that they could be cured pose unique challenges for physicians and shows a need for clear communication between patients and their physicians regarding the outcome of treatment and quality of life.
Dr. Loh graciously shared with us a summary of her study.
Chance of Cure in Advanced Cancer: What Do Older Patients Believe and How Are These Beliefs Related to Their Preferences?
Kah Poh (Melissa) Loh, MD; Supriya Mohile, MD, MS (University of Rochester Medical Center)
Paul Duberstein, Ph.D. (Rutgers University)
Despite treatment advances in many cancers, stage 4 or metastatic cancers (with the exception of a few) remain incurable. Existing treatments aim to prolong life in this setting but will never be able to take the cancer away and have it never return. Many older adults have other medical problems, are on many medications, and have limitations in daily activities. Therefore, it is important that older adults have a good understanding of their cancer and the goals of treatment when making decisions. We know that many older adults would prefer to maintain their ability to perform daily activities at home, their ability to think, and their quality of life rather than simply living longer.
In this study that we presented at the American Society of Clinical Oncology (ASCO) Palliative and Supportive Care in Oncology, we estimated how many older patients were absolutely certain that their advanced cancer could be cured. We were also interested in the relationship between their trade-off preferences and beliefs about the chance of cure. This was a sub-study of a larger study that looked at whether or not a comprehensive assessment of health in a wide variety of domains would improve communication (Principal Investigator: Supriya Mohile). The domains that were assessed included their functionality, memory and thinking, health status, medications, nutritional status, psychological health, and social support. The study included patients aged ≥70 years with incurable cancer who were considering or receiving any kind of cancer treatment and had an impairment in one of the domains.
We asked patients about their beliefs about the chance of cure using the following question: “What do you believe are the chances that your cancer will go away and never come back with treatment? Options were: 100%, >50%, 50/50, <50%, 0%, or uncertain. The breakdown is shown below; 5.3% of older patients believed with 100% certainty that their advanced cancer will be cured.
We then presented the patients the following statement: “Maintaining my QoL is more important to me than living longer”; 73% agreed, 19% were neutral, and 8% disagreed. What we found was that those who disagreed with this statement were more likely to believe that there was a 100% chance that their cancer will be cured.
Based on this, we think that in order to help older patients with advanced cancer understand their prognosis, it is important that physicians ask about their preferences, values, emotions, and fears.
You can review the abstract from ASCO 2018 here: https://meetinglibrary.asco.org/record/167043/abstract.
We invite you to ask questions and comment in our community forums!
Hi Carole, Welcome to Grace. If the adrenal is the only place that cancer has been seen since your lobectomy it could be that it's what's known as a precocious metastasis/oligoprogression...
These approaches haven't been directly compared, and it really depends on who can do the job and what they say is appropriate to expect in terms of side effects. In...
Thank you so much I will call Monday and get your second opinion going. No ca anywhere else- lungs no change 2 years- but complicated by a gi bleed they cannot...
Welcome to Grace. If the TKI is working except for one or 2 places local treatment such as radiation can be used to get rid of the resistant cells...
I forgot to tell you that Grace is having its annual OncTalk live forum online Saturday, Dec. 11 at 8 am Pacific and 11 am Eastern
It will be invaluable to...
This is indeed a happy Thanksgiving in our house. I'll post about it at soon but we've just come out of a dark place and are feeling so hopeful today.
Janine I am so happy to hear things like this. What you can or feel comfortable sharing, know that we are here! You are a very important part of the GRACE...