Article and Video CATEGORIES

Cancer Journey

Search By

Dr. Jack West is a medical oncologist and thoracic oncology specialist who is the Founder and previously served as President & CEO, currently a member of the Board of Directors of the Global Resource for Advancing Cancer Education (GRACE)

 

Sex Differences in Lung Cancer Risk and Outcome
Author
Howard (Jack) West, MD

We have rarely divided cancers along the lines of sex, except for the obvious ones like breast, prostate, testicular, ovarian, etc., but there is growing evidence to begin to consider patient sex in the field of lung cancer. (As a semantic point for the delicate souls out there who will wonder why I use the word “sex” throughout this post (but notice my restraint in not putting it in bold), it isn’t an attempt to broaden interest by turning OncTalk into an adults only website: the term gender applies to whether a person identifies themselves as male or female as a sociological variable, but patient sex is the biological, genetic and non-transferable assignment). We’ll start to explore some of what we’re learning, and I understand that some very intriguing information on sex-based differences will be presented at the American Society for Clinical Oncology Annual Conference in early June. I’ll give you those updates when they’re publicly available.

First, there’s the issue of the changing patterns of lung cancer. A review of a large database of cancer patients (free full article here) revealed that younger patients with lung cancer (<50) are more likely to be women, and that women disproportionately develop adenocarcinomas and small cell lung cancer, with a relative dearth of squamous cell carcinomas. This suggests that there are differences in the risk factors that can lead to lung cancer in men vs. women. In addition, I’ve described in a previous post some work by Dr. Heather Wakelee at Stanford that shows a disproportionate number of women who are life-long never-smokers in multiple case series.

Obviously, when we see biological differences between the sexes, an important question is whether hormonal differences may be responsible. Estrogen is directly involved with the development of breast and ovarian cancer, but it now also appears that estrogen is involved with lung cancer as well. Unlike breast and lung cancer, Unlike breast cancer, where there is an estrogen receptor commonly expressed that is known as ER-alpha, lung cancer commonly expresses ER-beta, and it is not more commonly expressed in lung tumors of women than men, suggesting that ER-beta levels may not be modulated by estrogen levels in the body. Lung tissue normally expresses this ER-beta receptor, more than any other tissues in the body outside of the reproductive tract. When ER-beta on lung tissue is activated in lab models (test tubes with cells or mouse models of cancer), cells grow and divide, so this leads us to think that perhaps blocking ER could be helpful. Moreover, ER interacts with EGFR, a setting in which sex-based differences have been well-described, leading some investigators to initiate studies in which both hormonal function and EGFR are targeted at the same time. More on that later.

There have been some mixed results on the correlation of estrogen exposure with risk of lung cancer and then outcomes in women who have lung cancer. Taioli and Wynder (reference here) showed that women who experienced early menopause had about a 70% reduction in risk of developing lung cancer, and that there is a markedly increased risk of developing adenocarcinomas among smoking women who had been on hormone replacement therapy (HRT). Another study (abstract here) looked at a large population of women in Sweden and found that estrogen replacement was associated with a modestly higher risk of women developing lung cancer, although the women on estrogen were also more likely to have smoked. However, other studies have reported that women on HRT do not appear to be at higher risk (abstract here) and may even have a decreased risk for developing lung cancer(abstract here).

A trial in breast cancer that included women treated for early stage disease, in which half of the patients received tamoxifen, which activates estrogen receptors, had an increased risk of developing different cancers later, most commonly lung cancer (abstract here).

One study was just reported by Dr. Ganti and colleagues (abstract here) that evaluated the survival of women who were diagnosed with lung cancer as a function of HRT exposure (minimum 6 weeks). In this report, the investigators reviewed the medical records of 498 women with lung cancer (NSCLC or SCLC, any stage) and found that there were some key differences. Women who had been on HRT were overall younger (median age 63 vs. 68 for those who hadn’t been on HRT), but more importantly that women on HRT had a significantly worse survival than women who had not been on HRT (median survival 79 vs. 39 months, p = 0.02):

Ganti Sex differences (click to enlarge)

As was seen by Taioli previously, the apparently detrimental effects of HRT were much more pronounced among women who smoked.

Overall, then, there are some discrepant results, but a majority of the literature suggests a potentially harmful effect of hormone therapy in women in terms of risk of developing lung cancer and outcomes in the setting of identified lung cancer. Next we’ll cover the differences by patient sex in responses to therapy.

Next Previous link

Previous PostNext Post

Related Content

Image
Clinical Trials Storytelling 2025
Article
GRACE is pleased to introduce three amazing individuals participating in the 2024-25 GRACE Clinical Trials Experiences Storytelling Program
Article
Advance directives are a powerful way to take control of healthcare choices. These documents allow you to outline preferences for medical care and specify end-of-life wishes. These documents can also be a way to appoint loved ones who you would like to help with these decisions, such as a healthcare proxy (someone to make decisions on your behalf, if you cannot). As cancer treatments can involve aggressive treatments and/or complex medical management, having advance directives ensures that your desires regarding treatment options and end-of-life care are clearly communicated. 
Image
2024-25 patient perspectives header
Article
Tell your story and help us help others! Apply online now for this paid opportunity. This program gives a voice to those who have experience in participating in a clinical trial for a cancer diagnosis. Your voice helps to educate and advocate for others who are in or who may be considering a clinical trial.  We want to hear from you!

Forum Discussions

Can SCLC also be treated with targeted therapy?

Hi amitchouhan,

Welcome to Grace. At this time, there aren't any targeted therapies to treat SCLC, but there are new treatments. Check out our latest OncTalk webinar from December. The last...

I was searching for this, Thank you so much for the info.

Glad to help.  FYI, I just edited the link, which has the agenda and links to oncologists' bios. Plus, the link is also on our home page, https://cancergrace.org/

Hope to see...

Recent Comments

JOIN THE CONVERSATION
Glad to help.  FYI, I just…
By JanineT GRACE … on
I was searching for this,…
By LilahStapleton on
Hi and welcome.  I'm sorry…
By JanineT GRACE … on
Hi amitchouhan,

Welcome to…
By JanineT GRACE … on