Article and Video CATEGORIES

Cancer Journey

Search By

Dr. Jack West is a medical oncologist and thoracic oncology specialist, and Executive Director of Employer Services at the City of Hope Comprehensive Cancer Center in Duarte, CA.

Doublet vs. Single Agent Chemo in the Elderly with Advanced NSCLC: France Offers a Definitive Answer
Wed, 09/29/2010 - 21:35
Howard (Jack) West, MD, Associate Clinical Professor, Medical Oncology, Executive Director, Employer Services, Founder, President and CEO of GRACE

Although the ASCO Plenary session presentation on ALK inhibition with crizotinib was a darling of the entire conference and led to a post I wrote about on the way back from the meeting, there was actually a second presentation on lung cancer in the plenary session that received far less attention, including by us here at GRACE. It asked the question of whether doublet therapy or single agent chemo for elderly patients with advanced NSCLC leads to better outcomes, and specifically superior survival. Without a novel targeted agent, it's been overshadowed, but it demonstrated a clear answer to a question that is very relevant, so it's high time to review its findings.

Dr. Quoix from France reviewed the IFCT-0501 trial, which randomized previously untreated stage III or IV NSCLC patients of age 70-89, with a good or more marginal performance status, to either carboplatin/Taxol (paclitaxel), with carbo all on the first day and the Taxol divided into three weekly doses every 4 weeks (4th week being an off week), vs. a single agent chemo arm of either Navelbine (vinorelbine) or Gemzar (gemcitabine) as two weekly doses in a three week cycle (3rd week being an off week), at the treating physician's discretion. All patients were to received Tarceva (erlotinib) as planned second line therapy.

quoix-schema (click on image to enlarge)

In general, either single agent or doublet chemotherapy for elderly patients (most typically defined as 70 and older) has been considered a very reasonable choice, as summarized in a prior post. Subset analyses of patients of any age have generally suggested that patients over 70 with a good performance status tend to perform very comparably to younger fit patients, and specifically that they tend to receive a survival benefit from platinum-based doublet chemotherapy if they are fit enough to tolerate it. A trial of marginal performance status patients demonstrated that doublet chemotherapy with carbo/Taxol in a molecularly unselected US population (presumably very disproportionately with no EGFR mutation) had a far superior survival with first line chemo than with the EGFR inhibitor Tarceva (erlotinib).

The French trial closed early, after an interim analysis of 451 enrolled patients with a median follow-up of 21.3 months revealed that the recipients of the carboplatin/Taxol doublet had a significantly longer median survival than those on the single agent arm. In fact, all of the efficacy endpoints were clearly superior with doublet chemotherapy. The median overall survival (OS) was 10.3 vs. 6.2 months (P = 0.0004), 1 year OS 45% vs. 27%, response rate 29% vs. 11% (P < 0.00001), and median progression-free survival 6.1 vs. 3.0 months (P = 0.00001).


A multivariate analysis looking at results as a function of various individual variables demonstrated that recipients of the doublet chemotherapy had a superior survival regardless of age, performance status, smoking history, or NSCLC histology. If the variable of what chemo was given is removed, patients with a good performance status had a better survival, as did those with no smoking history or an adenocarcinoma; these findings have been observed in many other trials of NSCLC.

Not surprisingly, doublet chemotherapy was more challenging and had significantly more frequent and severe side effects in several categories, including moderate to severe neutropenia (low WBC: 54% vs. 10%, P < 0.00001), fevers with neutropenia (10% vs. 3%, p = 0.004), moderate to severe thrombocytopenia (low platelets: 6% vs. 1%, P = 0.004), and moderate to severe neuropathy (3% vs. 0%, P = 0.015).

Though it's possible to criticize this trial for not including the same agent in both arms (such as carbo/Taxol vs. single agent Taxol, or carbo/Gemzar vs. Gemzar), there really isn't a clear standard single agent first line chemo for elderly patients, and all of these regimens are rather commonly used and very reasonable choices. The differences in outcomes shown here are convincing and also corroborate another trial, out of Japan, that looked just at cisplatin/Taxotere (docetaxel) vs. Taxotere alone in patients 70-74 and also showed that the doublet was superior.

At this point, I'd have to conclude that the data have been pretty consistent supporting the idea that platinum-based doublet chemotherapy, with a carboplatin-based regimen to be recommended for the clear majority of elderly patients by most oncologists, is associated with better survival. Doublet chemotherapy is going to be excessive for at least some elderly patients, and other patients may simply want to prioritize minimal side effects and be more inclined for single agent chemo, but it's become increasingly clear that there is an incremental benefit to first line doublet chemotherapy in older patients, just as in younger patients with advanced NSCLC.

Next Previous link

Previous PostNext Post

Related Content

Mandarin LCVL
王林医生用普通话讨论重要的肺癌信息。这些信息包括靶向治疗、晚期疾病的症状、循环肿瘤 DNA、治疗方案等。我们鼓励您与社区中说普通话的人分享。 Dr. Lin Wang discusses important lung cancer information in Mandarin. This information includes targeted therapy, symptoms of advanced disease, circulating tumor DNA, treatment options, and more. We encourage you to share this with the Mandarin speakers in your community. To watch the complete Playlist visit:…;  
Tell your story!  Apply now for the Clinical Trials Experiences through Storytelling Program
We are excited to launch our third year of this program; tell your story and help us help others! Apply Online Now!     GRACE Patient Perspectives: Clinical Trials Experiences Storytelling Program Overview  
Blood Cancer OncTalk
Blood Cancer OncTalk was a live presentation that brought together top oncologists to discuss emerging concepts and treatment options in blood cancer. The program was chaired by Dr. Aaron Goodman, with the participation of Dr. Mazie Tsang, Hematologist / Oncologist; Dr. Autumn Jeong, Hematologist / Oncologist; Dr. Shaji Kumar, Hematologist / Oncologist; and Dr. Sridevi Rajeeve, Hematologist / Oncologist.

Forum Discussions

Hi Caregiver and welcome to Grace.  I'm sorry that you need to be here and hope we can help.  Osimertinib has better efficacy than gefitinib (including OS and reaching the brain)...

Hi Bob, Welcome to Grace.  I'm sorry about your sil.  Unfortunately, cancer becomes resistant to TKIs like tagrisso.  Sometimes all of the cancer becomes resistant at once and sometimes just parts...

Recent Comments

Hi Tammy,  Welome to Grace. …
By JanineT GRACE … on Tue, 05/16/2023 - 13:44
By Tndiuka10 on Fri, 05/12/2023 - 21:13
Hi Caregiver and welcome to…
By JanineT GRACE … on Fri, 05/12/2023 - 14:20
Hi Bob, Welcome to Grace.  I…
By JanineT GRACE … on Tue, 05/02/2023 - 12:29