Article and Video CATEGORIES

Cancer Journey

Search By

Dr. Jack West is a medical oncologist and thoracic oncology specialist who is the Founder and previously served as President & CEO, currently a member of the Board of Directors of the Global Resource for Advancing Cancer Education (GRACE)

 

Is the Association of ERCC1 with Survival Differences in NSCLC Sex-Specific?
Author
Howard (Jack) West, MD

Some interesting work coming out of Denmark is evaluating the association of tumor ERCC1 expression with outcomes of inoperable patients receiving carboplatin and gemcitabine, and suggesting that the association of different outcomes depending on tumor ERCC1 expression is sex-specific.

To provide a very brief review of a subject covered in a prior post, ERCC1 is a protein that works to repair DNA damage, whether it is caused by a cancer or by certain chemotherapy drugs (which work by damaging the DNA of cancer cells), such as cisplatin or carboplatin. ERCC1 has been studied in a variety of cancers, and essentially the evidence has been pretty consistent in showing that patients with high ERCC1 levels seem to do better if not getting chemo (presumably because ERCC1 can help reverse the cancer's effect on DNA of normal cells) but do worse if getting chemotherapy, at least platinum-based chemo (because ERCC1 undoes the DNA-damaging effects of chemo on cancer cells).

The work out of Denmark looked at the association of survival with ERCC1 protein expression among 163 patients with inoperable NSCLC. In some parts of Europe they treat all inoperable people with chemotherapy rather than give chemo and radiation concurrently to potentially curable patients locally advanced or "medically inoperable" (not fit enough to tolerate surgery) disease, so this mix of patients is not just those with metastatic NSCLC. As has been seen in some other work with advanced NSCLC that showed better survival in patients with low tumor ERCC1 expression who received cisplatin-based chemotherapy, this trial showed an overall superior survival in patients who had low ERCC1 protein expression (58% of the whole population) and received carboplatin/gemcitabine. However, the difference in survival by ERCC1 status was only seem among the half of patients on the trial who were men. No difference in survival was seen among women with high vs. low ERCC1 expression.

This work is interesting, though with just 163 patients who have a range of stages being treated, the relatively small population and wide variability of patients limits what we can conclude. I think it's helpful to get some information showing a correlation of ERCC1 expression with outcomes on a carboplatin-based chemotherapy regimen, since we very commonly use carboplatin instead of cisplatin for patients with advanced NSCLC. The fact that the results showed a difference only in male patients is unexpected, since this hasn't been observed before, though a sex-based difference also hasn't been looked for in much of the past work on ERCC1. We are appreciating more and more that there may be important differences between men and women with lung cancer (besides the obvious ones), but we still don't know as much as we'd like to about that.

In the meantime, I would not presume that this is a clinically significant difference unless it's observed in other studies, since it could just be a random, spurious observation in a single relatively small trial. It does give us reason to pause about becoming too convinced that we know the whole story with ERCC1 and should be using it now for clinical decision-making. Though I have been impressed with the early work on it, I also recognize that this work has nearly all been retrospective, and we don't have any evidence yet that using it to prospectively assign treatment improves survival. For now, I see this work as one more piece of a puzzle that is still taking shape. Though we may be moving toward molecularly-based treatments, we need to ensure that we really understand the signals before we change our clinical practice to follow the early leads.

Next Previous link

Previous PostNext Post

Related Content

Image
Clinical Trials Storytelling 2025
Article
GRACE is pleased to introduce three amazing individuals participating in the 2024-25 GRACE Clinical Trials Experiences Storytelling Program
Article
Imagine your body's defense system, the lymphatic system, suddenly turning against you. This is the reality for those facing lymphoma, a cancer of the immune system's crucial network. This article delves into the complexities of lymphoma, exploring its various forms, from the aggressive to the indolent, and examining the latest breakthroughs in treatment, including the groundbreaking POLARIX trial and cutting-edge therapies for relapsed cases. Whether you're a patient, a loved one, or simply curious about this complex disease, this comprehensive overview will provide valuable insights into the current state of lymphoma care and the promising future of research.
Image
Melanoma Video Library
Video
In these videos, Dr. Autumn Starnes gives an overview of melanoma's prevalence and risk factors. She also discusses the ABCDE method of self-screening for skin cancer, common misconceptions regarding people of color, and melanoma, and how a person can lower their risk of developing melanoma, among other relevant topics regarding melanoma.  To watch the complete playlist, click here. 

Forum Discussions

Can SCLC also be treated with targeted therapy?

Hi amitchouhan,

Welcome to Grace. At this time, there aren't any targeted therapies to treat SCLC, but there are new treatments. Check out our latest OncTalk webinar from December. The last...

I was searching for this, Thank you so much for the info.

Glad to help.  FYI, I just edited the link, which has the agenda and links to oncologists' bios. Plus, the link is also on our home page, https://cancergrace.org/

Hope to see...

Recent Comments

JOIN THE CONVERSATION
Glad to help.  FYI, I just…
By JanineT GRACE … on
I was searching for this,…
By LilahStapleton on
Hi and welcome.  I'm sorry…
By JanineT GRACE … on
Hi amitchouhan,

Welcome to…
By JanineT GRACE … on