Article and Video CATEGORIES

Cancer Journey

Search By

Lung Cancer Video Library - Potential Advantages, Disadvantages and Limitations of Lung Cancer Screening
Author
GRACE Videos and Articles
Image
GRACE Cancer Video Library - Lung

GCVL_LU-A06_Potential_Advantages_Disadvantages_Limitations_Lung_Cancer_Screening

 

Dr. Gerard Silvestri, Medical University of South Carolina, discusses the benefits and drawbacks of lung cancer screenings.

 

Download Transcript

 

Transcript

Lung cancer screening is something that’s quite new in the United States. In 2010, the data was published on a 50,000 person trial where patients were either randomly allocated to get a CT (CAT) scan of their chest, a low dose radiation CT scan, or a chest x-ray, and the study showed a 20% reduction in lung cancer mortality in the patients who got screened for lung cancer with a CT.

There are a few things that you need to understand about that trial. One, it only included patients between the ages of 55 and 74; two, you had to have smoked at least 30 pack-years — that’s 30 years at a pack a day, or for example, 15 years at two packs a day. So you need to have a certain smoking history and be of a certain age to enter into that trial, and now patients in that age range with that smoking history are eligible to be screened for lung cancer with a yearly CT.

The advantage is that you hope to get the cancer when it’s quite small, and so it can be resected with a surgery, taken out, and that patient will have a better chance of being cured of their cancer because as we get to more advanced stages like when the cancer has spread outside of the chest, the hope for a complete cure is lessened. Early stage cancer, screen-detected cancer, has a better chance for cure.

There are some disadvantages to screening though that people need to be aware of. About one quarter of the time, patients who have a scan will have a spot on their lung, or a nodule, or a lesion it’s sometimes called — a quarter of the time those spots are there, and 96% of the time they’re benign spots, but they still need to be evaluated. Sometimes they’re evaluated just with following up with a CT scan, sometimes they’re evaluated with a biopsy, and even sometimes it requires surgery to get those out. That can cause a lot of anxiety in patients and certainly put them at risk for unnecessary procedures, particularly if you’re taking out something that was going to be benign all along. So that’s some of the disadvantage of being screened for lung cancer.

Also, as folks get older, so when you get up into that 75-77 age range, you also have other comorbidities, other things, other health issues that make it difficult for you to undergo surgery, and so some patients may not want to be screened if they have other health problems that may preclude a long life expectancy.

Overall, screening is being implemented in the United States the same way breast cancer screening was implemented years ago in the United States, and we’re doing it very carefully to make sure the patients are of the appropriate setting. The other thing we’re doing is making sure that if patients are smoking, that they get some smoking cessation as part of their screening endeavor.

Video Language

Next Previous link

Previous PostNext Post

Related Content

Image
Blood Cancer OncTalk
Article
In this series of videos, Dr. Aaron Goodman chairs the discussion along with speakers Drs. Tycel Phillips, Sridevi Rajeeve, Marco Ruiz and Alankrita Taneja.  Topics include:

Forum Discussions

Hi ramosking,  Welcome to Grace.  I'm sorry you're suffering.  It doesn't sound like you have a pancoast tumor. It does seem like you should see your PCP or a pulmonologist for...

Hey, So I went to the Doctor and explained all my symptoms I was having, They did some examining by listening to my lungs with a stethoscope, They said my lungs...

I hope you find some help through your doc or PT. 

Take care,

Janine

Hi Revtoby, Welcome to Grace.  I'm sorry you and your wife are worried about cancer but we couldn't say whether or not your wife's leison is cancer no matter how much...

Canyil, I'm sorry your father and you are going through this. While we can't give urgent help we are her to help offer info and resources to help make the best...

Recent Comments

JOIN THE CONVERSATION
Xalkori (crizotinib) is a…
By philipphilip on
I hope you find some help…
By JanineT GRACE … on
Went to doctor
By ramosking on
Hi ramosking,  Welcome to…
By JanineT GRACE … on