Article and Video CATEGORIES

Cancer Journey

Search By

Dr. Jack West is a medical oncologist and thoracic oncology specialist who is the Founder and previously served as President & CEO, currently a member of the Board of Directors of the Global Resource for Advancing Cancer Education (GRACE)

 

Surgery or No Surgery: What Would You Choose?
Author
Howard (Jack) West, MD

I'm heading off today to Hawaii (Maui), which I must hasten to add is for a conference, the Eighth International Lung Cancer Congress, not just a vacation, although working in Hawaii often seems better than time off at home. The meeting not only includes a lot of good lectures and debates, but it gives us the opportunity to actually discuss the importance and implications of the trials that were just presented a few weeks before at ASCO. Some of the important clinical trials and collaborations are developed during free hours at this meeting.

In addition to participating in a panel discussion on optimal management of never-smokers with lung cancer, I'll be arguing in a debate on how to manage stage IIIA NSCLC. The specific topic is whether this stage of cancer should be treated with surgery (generally combined with chemo and sometimes also radiation) or whether chemo and radiation together without surgery should be more commonly recommended. Some of my posts that discuss the controversy about this issue are here and here. My debate will be with a surgeon from the MD Anderson Cancer Center, so it should be a challenge, but it's all pretty light-hearted. We couldn't have a debate if there was a clear right answer.

In lung cancer, as in many other types of cancer, people generally receive surgery if it's possible to resect the tumor, and other treatments are considered alternatives. Part of this is historical: before there was chemotherapy or radiation, surgery was the only way to manage cancer. In addition, surgeons are often the first specialists to meet a cancer patient, since they often perform the biopsies that establish a tissue diagnosis. And, in truth, surgery often is a very effective treatment, particularly for earlier stage cancers.

So I have a question for members here: would most people definitely prefer surgery if it's possible ("get it out!"), and consider non-surgical treatments to be a less desirable alternative, or would people be very happy to pursue a non-invasive approach if it produces comparable results? I'm making this the new polling topic for the next several days. When options produce similar outcomes, patient preferences should be a key component of what strategy to follow. So offer your comments here, and I hope you'll vote in the poll on the right column.

Next Previous link

Previous PostNext Post

Related Content

Article
The journey to conquer lung cancer is paved with scientific discovery, and the identification of the EGFR and ALK genes as crucial players marks a significant milestone. Unraveling how mutations in these seemingly small segments of our DNA can unleash the destructive force of cancer has opened up exciting new therapeutic avenues. This exploration delves into the cutting-edge world of EGFR and ALK-targeted therapies, highlighting the progress made and the ongoing quest for even more effective and personalized strategies to combat this formidable disease.
Image
Rare cancers
Video
In these videos,  Dr. Jared Weiss gives a brief overview of NUT Carcinoma, discusses treatment options and possible future treatment.  To watch the complete playlist, click here.  
Article
Don't let the word "small" deceive you. Small cell lung cancer (SCLC) casts a long shadow, impacting lives with its aggressive nature and the complexities of its treatment. But while the challenges are real, so is the progress. Breakthroughs in small cell lung cancer treatment offer hope. Immunotherapy plus chemo-radiation improves survival by 22 months. Screening catches it early.

Forum Discussions

Can SCLC also be treated with targeted therapy?

Hi amitchouhan,

Welcome to Grace. At this time, there aren't any targeted therapies to treat SCLC, but there are new treatments. Check out our latest OncTalk webinar from December. The last...

I was searching for this, Thank you so much for the info.

Recent Comments

JOIN THE CONVERSATION
Yes, it's crucial to discuss…
By JanineT GRACE … on
Definitely a good idea to…
By OakleeFarnick on
Thank you for sharing
By LeviDrake on
Hi bluesun,I don't know of…
By JanineT GRACE … on